I opened my copy of The Perfect Scoop and gasp! What? No pumpkin ice cream recipe? hmmm. Sweet potato ice cream just won’t do. David Lebovitz what were you thinking not including Pumpkin Ice Cream in your book? I’m glad I wasn’t the only one perplexed by this omission since you happened to post one on your blog in response to our madness…
Lebovitz has a magical way of combining cream eggs and sugar into the most delicious creamy treats. I was really happy to find a recipe he only ever so slightly changed from chef Karen DeMasco in her cookbook The Craft of Baking. You should read his blog post. It’s quite witty and apparently he got some stares while walking home with a rather large but thin butternut squash (subbed squash for pumpkins).
The original recipe used canned pumpkin which I adore. I have a plethora of pumpkin recipes using canned pumpkin, and it’s really my favorite. Fresh pumpkins don’t usually give you the thick consistency of the canned version unless you do a lot of straining. I can never tell a difference in the end product from fresh vs canned pumpkin. That said, I decided to stick to good ole Libby’s. She must have been quite the lady.
I have no idea why I never tried pumpkin ice cream until now. It seems to fit well into fall desserts and even though its cold outside, you can cozy up with a blanket and movie and enjoy some delicious spiced ice cream. Michael and I happen to do this often, and the tub of ice cream disappears at an alarming rate.
I absolutely loved this ice cream recipe. I’ll be making it at least once more this winter but next time I’ll have to place it on a warm slab of gingerbread cake topped with candied pecans. Yum. Good thing you can’t see me drooling.
If you don’t have an ice cream machine, you should at least try making the candied pecans. They are addictive and delicious and would make a great addition to your holiday cookie trays.
1 lb Pecan halves (trader joe’s are great)
1 egg white
1 T water + 1 tsp vanilla
1/2 tsp cinnamon
3/4 tsp salt
1 C sugar
Preheat the oven to 250˚F and line a rimmed baking sheet with foil. Whisk egg white until frothy and water and pour into a gallon size ziplock bag. Add in the nuts and shake to coat. In another bowl/bag combine the sugar and cinnamon and add the nuts. Make sure they are evenly coated and spread onto a rimmed baking sheet. Bake for 45 minutes to 60 minutes stirring every 15 minutes. Make sure you taste one or two after 45 minutes because they could be done then. If not, keep cooking another 10-15. Cool on tray and store in an airtight container.